Skip to content

Pros & Cons of Crypto IRAs

Disclosure: Our content does not constitute financial advice. Speak to your financial advisor. We may earn money from companies reviewed. The owners of this website may be paid when you complete a form, click a link or call a phone number. The content on this website, including any positive reviews, may not be neutral or independent.

Gold and other precious metal IRAs are an investment and carry risk. Consumers should be alert to claims that customers can make a lot of money in these or any investment with little risk. As with any investment, you can lose money and past performance is not a guarantee of future performance results. Consumers should also obtain a clear understanding of the fees associated with any investment before agreeing to invest.

Our content is intended to be used for general information purposes only. It is very important to do your own analysis before making any investment based on your own personal circumstances and consult with your own investment, financial, tax and legal advisers.

Overview of cryptocurrency-based IRAs

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) does not recognize any particular Individual Retirement Account (IRA) created for cryptocurrency. As a result, when you hear the terms "cryptocurrency IRA" or "Bitcoin IRA," they refer to an IRA with digital currencies as part of its assets.

Since 2014, the IRS has taxed cryptocurrencies as property, which means they are treated similarly to stocks, bonds, and other investment devices when it comes to taxation. They cannot be contributed by the account holder into an IRA, just like the other investments. This implies that you need a custodian's assistance if you wish to add crypto to your IRA.

Finding a custodian that accepts crypto in an IRA might be complicated. Fortunately, alternative investments like cryptocurrency are more commonly permitted by self-directed IRAs (SDIRAs).

Custodians and other businesses that help investors add cryptocurrency to their IRAs have grown in popularity. Examples include BitIRA, Equity Trust, and Bitcoin IRA, one of the industry's first pioneers.

What Crypto IRAs Offer in Terms of Benefits?

Diversification

You may notice that one can diversify retirement portfolios by adding cryptocurrency assets. This might aid in safeguarding such retirement assets in the future in the case of a significant market decline or other turbulent events.

Growth Prospects

Investors willing to add crypto assets to their IRAs typically feel that cryptocurrency will continue to increase in prominence and accessibility in the future, maybe more so than diversification. Because of their long-term orientation, IRAs are an excellent vehicle for investments with tremendous potential over decades.

Although a significant risk of loss is associated with a potential for development, some investors believe that the likelihood of gain outweighs this risk.

Tax Planning

Including digital currencies in retirement plans with a tax approach may be viable if you're set on investing in cryptocurrencies and want to avoid paying high capital gains taxes. For instance, putting cryptocurrency in a Roth IRA enables you to avoid paying taxes on potential capital gains because you previously paid taxes on the money in the account.

You must pay income taxes when you withdraw funds from a traditional IRA where you've invested your crypto. If your income—and presumably your tax bracket—decreases after you start withdrawing from your IRA, this might offer you a tax advantage.

You pay taxes only when you withdraw from a regular IRA; thus, trading within it has the same tax consequences as stock trading within one. The tax treatment of trading crypto from a Roth IRA would be the same as holding it there.

The Drawbacks of Crypto IRAs

Price sensitivity

Because of its high volatility, crypto is a difficult sell to many as a retirement investment. For instance, the most popular cryptocurrency, Bitcoin, regularly goes through substantial price swings; since 2009, it has gone from having absolutely no value to $69,000 before dropping down to a constant value of roughly $20,000 in early 2022. This makes it impractical for someone who requires solid and liquid assets as they approach retirement; nevertheless, it can make sense for someone who has a good number of years before retirement.

Risk

Volatility increases the chance of loss by causing significant value movements. For instance, if you paid $1,000 for a cryptocurrency, its value can drop by more than 75% over the course of a few months and never rise again. In this scenario, you would lose $750; higher investments would increase the losses.

Many cryptocurrencies are not backed by organisations or physical assets, so investors and the general public may lose interest in them after you buy them. Most cryptocurrencies are solely held up by people's conviction that they have value; if this conviction ever wavers significantly, cryptocurrencies risk collapsing and wiping out billions of dollars.

Trading and Account Fees

The fees are yet another significant drawback of putting crypto in an IRA. Trading in cryptocurrencies through an IRA is distinct from ordinary stock trading and trading on platforms that do not act as custodians.

Because self-directed IRA service providers are not subject to broker fiduciary obligations, it is your duty to evaluate the risks involved with the crypto markets and take action to reduce those risks.

Throughout the investing process, fees for crypto trading might take many different shapes. The fees include setup fees at the beginning, custody and trading fees, and yearly maintenance fees. For instance, opening a $50,000 self-directed IRA account for trading may incur several thousand dollars in setup fees, depending on the provider. Furthermore, the companies offering these services demand recurrent fees for custody and upkeep.

Finally, the trading partner and custodian of the service provider charge fees for each cryptocurrency transaction. A typical supplier may charge 1% or a fixed fee for each sale, in addition to 3.5% per transaction for purchases.

Relevant Considerations

Due to specific needs for cryptocurrency, such as security or custody, service fees for IRA accounts tend to increase. The IRS may require more reporting from IRA custodians who deal with cryptocurrencies; this might result in higher costs for IRA holders who invest in cryptocurrencies.

If you're seeking a custodian to carry out your crypto desires, there are a lot of swindlers or dishonest businesses that offer their services. Alerts concerning bogus cryptocurrency IRAs have been released by the Securities and Exchange Commission and the U.S. Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). False crypto IRA firms who assert the IRS has approved them have received a warning from the CFTC. 

If you want to ensure your money is being used wisely while considering a crypto IRA, it's advisable to see a licenced financial advisor who is experienced with cryptocurrencies.

Can I Purchase crypto in a Self-Directed Roth IRA?

Although it's not permitted to buy cryptocurrencies and put them in a Roth IRA, you may use money from your IRA to purchase cryptocurrency and put it in your retirement account by using a custodial service provider.

Can Cryptocurrency Be Placed in a Roth IRA?

While you are permitted to utilise IRA custodians to add cryptocurrency to your IRA, IRS regulations prohibit you from doing so yourself.

Can I Purchase Cryptocurrency Using My IRA?

Yes. Once more, in order to add bitcoins to your IRA, a custodian must purchase them.

Next steps

If you want to learn more about investing in a crypto IRA, we recommend you grab a copy of this FREE crypto investment guide over at My Digital Money.

Related articles

Goldco review

Birch Gold review

Augusta Precious Metals review

Regal Assets review

Learn more about investing in gold

Close up of business trader man working on crypto currency markets with blockchain technology - Decentralized finance and stock exchange concept